The Pros and Cons of the 4 Major Sports Card Grading Company

In the world of sports cards and trading cards, grading has become one of the most important steps in determining a card’s value, authenticity, and long-term investment potential. A card graded by a trusted company carries far more weight on the secondary market than an ungraded one, often multiplying its value. However, not all grading companies are the same. Each has its own standards, reputation, pricing, and pros and cons.

In this post, we’ll break down the major grading companies in the hobby—PSA, BGS (Beckett Grading Services), SGC (Sportscard Guaranty Corporation), and CSG (Certified Sports Guaranty)—and highlight the strengths and weaknesses of each.

PSA (Professional Sports Authenticator)

Pros:

1.  Market leader and most recognized brand in the hobby
2.  Highest resale values, especially for PSA 10s
3.  Strong population reports for tracking rarity
4.  Generally consistent grading standards

 Cons:

1.  Longer turnaround times historically
2.  More expensive submission fees
3.  Slabs considered less “premium” in design compared to Beckett

BGS (Beckett Grading Services)

Pros:

1.  Subgrades provide detailed breakdowns (centering, corners, edges, surface)
2.  BGS 9.5 and Black Label are highly respected in the hobby
3.  Great for modern cards, especially autographs and memorabilia
4.  Thick, premium slab design

Cons:

1. Lower resale value than PSA (unless Black Label)
2. Inconsistent grading in recent years
3. Decline in market dominance

SGC (Sportscard Guaranty Corporation)

Pros:

1. Known as the go-to for vintage cards (T206, pre-war, etc.)
2. Distinct black insert looks great with older cards
3. Faster turnaround and reasonable pricing
4. Growing popularity with modern cards during PSA backlogs

Cons:

1. Lower resale premiums for modern cards compared to PSA
2. Market perception as a “secondary” option for non-vintage
3. Less brand recognition with casual collectors

CSG (Certified Sports Guaranty)

Pros:

1. Backed by the same group that runs CGC (comics) and NGC (coins)
2. Extremely strict grading standards — a CSG 10 is hard to earn
3. Sleek, crystal-clear slabs with updated design
4. More affordable submissions than PSA/BGS

Cons:

1. Lower resale values compared to PSA, BGS, and even SGC
2. Early label design hurt perception (improved now)
3. Still newer and smaller market share

Comparison Chart: Grading Companies at a Glance

Company	Strengths	Weaknesses	Best For	Resale Value	Turnaround	Pricing
PSA	Market leader, highest resale, strong pop reports	Long turnaround, higher fees, basic slab design	Modern rookies, investment cards	⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐	Slow (varies)	High
BGS	Subgrades, Black Label prestige, thick premium slabs	Lower resale vs PSA, inconsistency, losing ground	Modern autos, patches, thick cards	⭐⭐⭐⭐	Moderate (slower lately)	High
SGC	Vintage authority, sleek black insert, faster turnaround	Lower resale on modern, less casual recognition	Vintage (pre-1980s), crossover subs	⭐⭐⭐	Fast	Moderate
CSG	Strict grading, affordable, crystal-clear slabs	Lower resale, newer brand, small market	Budget grading, collectors wanting strict 10s	⭐⭐	Fast	Low/Moderate

Which Card Grading Company Is Best? 

The truth is, the “best” grading company depends on your goals:

1. If you want maximum resale value → PSA is still the king.
2. If you want detailed subgrades and premium slabs → BGS is a strong choice.
3. If you’re grading vintage → SGC is widely regarded as the best.
4. If you want affordability and tough standards → CSG is worth considering.

Many serious collectors even mix and match depending on the card type.

Final Thoughts

Grading is one of the most important aspects of the modern hobby, influencing both presentation and long-term value. While PSA dominates the resale market, BGS, SGC, and CSG each offer unique advantages. Ultimately, your choice comes down to whether you’re collecting for investment, aesthetics, or preservation.

No matter which company you choose, grading remains one of the best ways to protect and add legitimacy to your collection.

*** About Memorabilia Displays***

Memorabilia Displays is the world's leading online sports collectible display case retailer. We work with every major supplier to bring you the biggest selection across all sports memorabilia cases all with free store wide shipping. We aim to deliver cases that fit every budget with the lowest prices to help you find what you need.